Most travellers stay in San Juan – here’s why I’d choose Aguadilla instead

If someone asked me where to stay in Puerto Rico for the first time, I’d probably recommend San Juan. But if they asked where I’d stay, my answer would almost always be Aguadilla. 

While San Juan is an excellent introduction to the archipelago, I can’t help but feel that many visitors are missing out. 

Instead, Aguadilla feels more relaxed and connected to everyday Puerto Rico. As a local, I think it’s a better place to stay for visitors who want more than just a checklist of attractions. 

San Juan is the go-to for first-time travelers

San Juan is one of the most popular places to stay in Puerto Rico, and for good reason.

Not only is the capital city home to Old San Juan, a 500-year-old Spanish colonial city known for housing impressive historical structures, including El Morro, but it’s also a convenient all-in-one destination for travelers. 

Neighborhoods like Condado, Miramar, and Santurce offer a great range of hotel options, from budget to luxury stays, that can accommodate families, couples, and budget travelers. 

When it comes to things to do, you never run out of them in San Juan. Even as a Puerto Rico local, I often find myself doing something new during my visits to the city. 

Activities range from museums to highly rated beaches, all within walking distance, and many of them are free or inexpensive. 

I’d also say San Juan has some of the most active nightlife in Puerto Rico, even on weekdays. After sunset, you can hop between bars and pubs in Old San Juan, Santurce, and Rio Piedras.

With the airport a short ride away and so much to do, it’s no wonder San Juan is the go-to option for many people. In fact, according to Puerto Rico’s 2024 visitor profile, most visitors stayed between San Juan and Carolina during their trip.

I’d especially recommend San Juan if you’re not renting a car, since much of the city is walkable. And if walking isn’t your thing, there are Uber and public transportation options to get around. 

San Juan and Aguadilla showcase different sides of Puerto Rico

That being said, despite being the epicenter of tourism, I believe San Juan shows only one side of Puerto Rico, and one that by no means represents everything the archipelago has to offer. 

Still, I recognize San Juan is the perfect introduction to Puerto Rico, especially for first-timers and travelers on a short weekend getaway.

The convenience of the capital city (and the fact that you can do so much without a car) is something many other towns in Puerto Rico can’t compete with.

When you compare San Juan to Aguadilla, you’ll come across the same challenges of many towns outside the metro region: you need to rent a car, hotels are scarce, and many of the attractions are outdoor-based.  

And still, I confidently believe many travelers overlook a part of Puerto Rico that deserves more attention. So what makes Aguadilla so special? Let’s break down the reasons.

I prefer Aguadilla for its slower lifestyle

Aguadilla is located on Puerto Rico’s northwest coast, roughly two hours from San Juan by car. 

And while driving there might be too much of a hassle for some visitors, what many people don’t know is that you can actually fly directly into Aguadilla from several US cities, a convenience many other Puerto Rico towns and regions lack.

But why even try? While San Juan is the perfect all-in-one destination, Aguadilla is the “slow down and fall in love with the Caribbean” alternative. 

The biggest difference between the two municipalities isn’t the number or the type of things to do – it’s the pace. 

Like many capital cities, San Juan moves fast, and it’s easy to get swept up in its rhythm, trying to fit as much as possible into a short visit. 

In Aguadilla, you naturally slow down. Regardless of what you have planned, you’ll find yourself wanting to stay a little longer in many places.

In this beach town, sitting by the ocean with a fritter and watching the sunset feels like enough. You stop worrying about what to do next and start enjoying where you are. That feeling is what keeps bringing me back.

Aguadilla has scenic hikes, secluded beaches, and amazing gastronomy

Hiking is one of my preferred things to do in Aguadilla and one of the things that makes me constantly feel like “I don’t want to leave yet”. 

For example, the first time I hiked to Survival Beach during the golden hour felt surreal, as if I had stumbled onto a hidden corner of the Caribbean. Nature reserves and coastal trails around Aguadilla offer some of the best hikes in Puerto Rico.

Not to mention, Aguadilla’s beaches are particularly popular. And whether you’re into snorkeling or beach bumming, you’re bound to find one you love. 

Some are easily accessible and great for mingling with locals, like Crash Boat and Rompeolas Beach, but my absolute favorites are the remote and hidden ones at the end of a hike, like Survival Beach.

This is also one of the places in Puerto Rico with a surf culture. The town not only has great surf in Surfer’s Beach and Playuela but also houses a World Surfing Reserve.

Culture and history enthusiasts will find multiple museums in Aguadilla’s downtown, including Puerto Rico’s only natural history museum. But you can also admire art outdoors. In fact, one of my favorite things to do downtown is to walk around admiring the street art.

Food is a big part of life in Aguadilla, with multiple gastronomic routes filled with restaurants and bars. I personally love eating fritters with a view of the beach. And while nightlife might not be a big thing like in San Juan, some spots like Timber & Blues still welcome night owls visiting the town. 

All of this is topped by what I consider some of the best sunsets in Puerto Rico. 

Aguadilla serves as a base to explore the west coast 

When I say travelers are missing out on this part of Puerto Rico, I’m not talking about this town specifically but about the complete northwest region. Aguadilla is the perfect launching point for exploring it.

The town has an airport, rental cars, and hotels. From here, you can take some of the best Puerto Rico day trips to coastal towns like Isabela and Rincón, or dive deep into the mountains in San Sebastián or Moca. 

Not to mention, you can take a boat tour to offshore islands like Desecheo, one of the best diving destinations in Puerto Rico. 

Location of Aguadilla in Puerto Rico

So when you stay in Aguadilla, you’re not only choosing it for the town itself but for the whole surrounding region and the experiences it offers. 

I’m talking about sunsets, rivers, mountain views, secluded beaches, historical ruins, and lots of great food spots, all without the crowds in San Juan. 

What more could you ask for from a vacation?

Who should stay in San Juan vs who will love Aguadilla?

Although Aguadilla is one of the places I recommend staying in Puerto Rico, it’s true that it is not the best option for everyone.

I admit San Juan is the go-to for first-time travelers who are short on time and are interested in exploring the capital’s most iconic landmarks. And if you’re not planning to rent a car, it is far easier to move around in San Juan than in Aguadilla. 

Similarly, if you’d rather have more hotel options, including luxury hotels like El Convento, then staying in San Juan might be the best alternative.

So, who should stay in Aguadilla? Returning travelers who have already explored San Juan may find Aguadilla a refreshing alternative. Or outdoor-loving visitors who are more interested in hikes, waterfalls, and nature reserves than historical sites. 

But I’d say Aguadilla is, more than anything, ideal for those looking to explore Puerto Rico at a slower and calmer pace. It’s for those who want to embrace local culture and discover remote landscapes without crowds. It’s the gateway to everything the West Coast offers. 

Aguadilla is much more about the quality than the quantity of things you can do.

A last word

So if you’re wondering where to stay while planning your trip to Puerto Rico, know one thing: Aguadilla might not be the right choice for everyone. But for people hoping to slow down, have easy access to nature, and develop a deeper connection to local culture, it’s hard to beat.

Of course, San Juan deserves its popularity. The city combines history, nightlife, and beaches, and makes it easy for travelers to get a taste of some of the best things to do in Puerto Rico, just a short ride from the main international airport. That’s exactly what makes it the right choice for many.

San Juan is where I recommend travelers begin their Puerto Rico journey.  Aguadilla is where I go when I want to experience the island myself. That’s why I keep coming back!

***

Whether you choose to stay in San Juan or venture off the beaten path to Aguadilla, make sure to read my top tips for visiting Puerto Rico next.